• Home
  • ABOUT
  • Contact
  • Reviews By Genre
    • Black Romance
    • Contemporary
    • Cowboys & Westerns
    • Erotic
    • Historical
    • New Adult
    • Paranormal
    • Romantic Elements
    • Science Fiction/Fantasy
    • Suspense
  • Reviews by Theme
    • Celebrities
    • Harlequin Category
    • Holiday
    • LGBTQIA
    • Low Heat
    • Millionaires & Billionaires
    • Motorcycle Club
    • Multicultural
      • Black
      • East Asian
      • South Asian
      • Latinx
      • Interracial
    • Novellas & Anthologies
    • Royalty
    • Small Town
    • Sports
  • Reviews By Trope

Romance and Sensibility

From First Page To HEA

Genre, Historical, Review, unrated

The Counterfeit Scoundrel by Lorraine Heath

August 28, 2023 Leave a Comment

This book has an interesting setup. David Blackwood made his fortune from investments so he picks up a side hustle helping married women get divorced by pretending to have affairs with them.

Daisy is an undercover private investigator tasked with finding out what goes on behind David’s closed doors. She goes undercover as a maid and there is an instant attraction between the two. The tension between the characters is palpable as they reluctantly pair up to solve a crime.

I lurk on the r/HistoricalRomance Reddit and there is a divide between people who want “realistic” historical romance and those who want historical romance through a 2020’s modern feminist lens. This book is FOR SURE the latter.

The hero is very much aware of his place of power and privilege in society. He hesitates to pursue Daisy until he is certain she isn’t really a maid. He looks down on men who abuse their power and one of the reasons he fakes affairs is because he is conscious of how unfair society and marriage laws are for women.

I do wish the book pushed the limits a little bit with David’s side hustle. The book goes out of its way to make it very clear that he is faking affairs and physical relations with these women. I kind of wish he was actually doing it for real. I think it would up the stakes and intrigue.

Heath’s books sort of confound me. Her books always seem to have two arcs. They start with the hero and heroine meeting under unusual circumstances and then the second half of the book is them meeting again and getting pulled into a new plot. It’s not my favorite structure but I think it worked better here than in her other books.

Currently Reading

Kat
Jess

A spin-off of Books and Sensibility, this blog was created in 2015 to talk exclusively about romance novels--From the first page to HEA !

Follow Us on Bloglovin’

Follow

Subscribe !

Reviews By Rating

  • 1 Star
  • 2 Star
  • 3 Star
  • 4 Star
  • 5 Star
  • Unrated

Search

Book Blog

Blog Archive

Abou

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
@romanceandsensibility

I came across this trope a lot this year -Kat #spicybooks #booktok

♬ Still Into You Drill - ShoBeatz

Social Slider

  • Time for a cover reveal! Wall Street Journal bestselling author @kennedyryan1 is excited to reveal the gorgeous special edition paperback
  • The small town of Honey Hill isn’t big enough to handle the feud between Mayor Lunden Pierce and Quade Cannon—-the
  • Picked this up on a trip to 2nd & Charles . Can’t wait to dive into this series - J
  • Welcome to the snack / book pairing challenge! To enter, tell me what snack you are pairing with your current
  • Happy Thanksgiving! I hope you’re joining us tomorrow for the Black Friday Readathon. You can still sign up using the
  • I’m ready for the Black Friday Readathon! If you want to join us and read all day on Black Friday
  • It
  • It
Design by SkyandStars.co

Copyright © 2025